I found this server that feels like the old prison days. It is not an OP prison so you do not start out super strong. You begin with basic tools and leather armor and you actually have to grind to get better gear.
You rank up by mining and doing the classic prison grind. The ranks go from A all the way up to Citizen and you can prestige for special rewards when you hit the top rank. You have to smelt your ores and then walk through pvp zones to sell them in the commissary so it feels risky and intense.
There are guards that protect new players and also enforce contraband rules. Swords and potions are illegal so if a guard sees you with them they will fight you. You can even get sent to solitary confinement by a guard if you have bad conduct.
There are some cool extra ways to make money like custom fishing and growing special illegal plants in your cell. You can rent a prison cell or a plot to store items build stuff grow illegal crops or make your own shop. There are quests for extra cash or special items and a bounty system if you want to put a price on someone and hunt players.
The server also has an auction house and parkour challenges around the prison. It is very focused on grinding pvp and that classic community prison feel where you actually have to work to reach parole and finally become a citizen.
The Pen – Classic Non OP Prison Grind

Build Verse Conquer Medieval Survival
emergent storytellinghardcore survivalinternational playerslong distance travelplayer-driven economy
Halcyon is a Lands PvP server that tries to feel like old school Minecraft survival but it still runs on the latest vanilla version 1.21.11. It is based in Australia and people also play from Europe the Americas and Asia so it feels pretty global.
The world is handmade and the rules are there to make things harder and slow down progress. Night cannot be skipped and healing is slow and only works in certain conditions. The server pushes you away from meta tricks and automation and more toward teamwork and being good at what you choose to do.
There is no teleportation so travel matters a lot. Players end up making roads waystations and even secret railways underground. Some crops and saplings only work in certain biomes so trading becomes important and regions start to feel different.
It does not force you into server lore. You can just start playing and your story grows as other players get involved. People have already been making art books myths and even weird superstitions from what happens in game.
GG.MINEWIND.NET New Server IPNightClub Semi Anarchy Vanilla Crossplay

The NightClub is a new semi anarchy vanilla Minecraft server made for people who are tired of pay to win stuff and annoying hoops just to play. It is meant to be simple and fair and actually fun.
It is open to everyone and it supports crossplay so Java and Bedrock players can join the same world. The vibe is survival with anarchy energy where you can explore talk share clips build stuff start chaos and make friends.
It is not about a huge list of rules. It is more about letting the world feel alive and letting people create their own stories as the community grows. The Discord is where people meet plan events and help shape what the community becomes.
GG.MINEWIND.NET New Server IPValecraft SMP Semi Vanilla 1.21.11

Valecraft SMP is a semi vanilla Minecraft server on 1.21.11 that is in the late stages of development and testing. It is looking for a few early players to help get things started.
It uses quality of life plugins like LuckPerms EssentialsX and WorldGuard plus a few others. The goal is to keep the game feeling like normal Minecraft while making things run smoother.
The server already has a small but active player base and a dedicated staff team. Feedback is taken through the Discord and staff can answer questions in chat.
GG.MINEWIND.NET New Server IPModded Squad PvP Weekly Events

Frontline Combat is a modded team based PvP server that feels like squad battles and battlefield matches.
They run regular events every week and they keep trying to make each one better. The server uses their own custom mods and content and they are looking for more players.
This server is Java only.
GG.MINEWIND.NET New Server IPHyscape Open Alpha Factions Lore Grind

Hyscape is a server where everyone is trying to get as rich as possible. You can farm for profit or raid other player bases and team up with factions to take over.
There is also a story being written for the lore. The big goals are to defeat dragons create crystals and rank up as you go.
It is free to play and they say they do not charge money for anything. The community is active and you can chat with other players. They also support the Simple Voice Chat mod.
The server is in open alpha right now and moving to beta soon. They are also hiring if you have skills in dev work or building.
Java is on 1.21.5 and Bedrock can join too.
GG.MINEWIND.NET New Server IP
